Brake light switch failure is the dominant issue in these complaints. Owners describe brake lights that won't illuminate when braking, with bulbs and fuses testing good—the switch itself is stuck or shorted. At least one owner replaced the switch twice within eight months, and several report brake lights failing again after dealer replacement. The switch failure cascades: it prevents the gear selector from moving out of park or drive in at least one documented case, and cruise control won't shut off when brakes are applied in another.
Bulb burnout happens repeatedly; one owner replaced lights 6–7 times over a lease period. Hyundai dealers acknowledge the Elantra burns out brake lights excessively but don't offer repair. Water intrusion at the tail lights leaks into the trunk during rain.
Critically, Hyundai told multiple owners the 2008 model isn't covered by the brake light switch recall (09V122000 covers only 2007; 13V113000 applies to some 2008s but Hyundai denied coverage to others). One crash occurred when brake lights failed to illuminate—the other driver didn't see the vehicle. Several owners were told by Hyundai to pay a diagnostic fee or bring the car in without promise of recall coverage.
Failure modes owners describe
Brake light switch failure
The brake stop lamp switch fails to illuminate brake lights when the brake pedal is depressed, or fails intermittently. Owners replace bulbs and check fuses only to find the switch is the root cause. Multiple owners report the switch sticking in on or off positions.
When: Reported between 13,137 miles and 92,846 miles; often recurs after dealer replacement
Symptoms owners cite: Brake lights do not illuminate when brakes are applied; All three brake lights fail simultaneously; Brake light switch sticks in on or off position; Brake lights work intermittently
Repairs/costs cited: Brake stop lamp switch assembly replacement; owners report costs not specified, but noted that fuses and bulbs test good prior to diagnosis
Recalls/TSBs owners mention: Recall 09V122000 covers only 2007 models, not 2008. Recall 13V113000 (Exterior Lighting, Service Brakes, Hydraulic) mentioned in some narratives. Hyundai advised many 2008 owners the vehicle is not covered by recalls and offered no assistance or demanded diagnostic fees.
Brake light bulb premature burnout
Brake light and tail light bulbs burn out repeatedly in short intervals, requiring multiple replacements within 1-2 years. Owner replaced bulbs 3-4 times within one year, then 6-7 times over the lease term.
When: Occurs within first 2 years of ownership; mileage range 20,000 to 30,000 cited in one case
Symptoms owners cite: Brake lights burn out repeatedly; Tail lights burn out repeatedly; Head light low beams burn out; Fog lights burn out; Multiple light failures requiring frequent replacement
Repairs/costs cited: Bulb replacement only; Hyundai acknowledged Elantra has a history of burning out brake lights but did not offer a remedy
Recalls/TSBs owners mention: Dealer stated Elantra has a history of burning brake lights out; no recall or repair program offered for this issue
Gear shift stuck in drive/park due to brake light switch
A shortage or fault in the brake lamp switch prevents the gear selector from shifting out of drive or park. The switch must be replaced to restore gear shift function; the problem recurred in at least one case after initial repair.
When: Occurred at approximately 13,137 miles; recurred eight months after first repair
Symptoms owners cite: Gear selector fails to shift from drive to park; Gear selector stuck and unable to move; Brake light switch detected with shortage causing gear selector failure
Repairs/costs cited: Brake stop lamp switch assembly replaced; replaced a second time eight months later when failure recurred
Recalls/TSBs owners mention: Manufacturer was made aware of the defect via dealer
Cruise control does not deactivate on brake application
When cruise control is engaged and the brake pedal is pressed, the cruise control does not disengage as expected. Owners report difficulty disengaging cruise control.
When: Mileage not specified; one report at 71,000 miles
Symptoms owners cite: Cruise control will not deactivate when brakes are depressed; Cruise control difficult to disengage
Repairs/costs cited: Dealer indicated the actuator would need replacement; repair status unknown
Tail light water intrusion
Water leaks into the trunk from the tail light lens assembly when the trunk is opened during rain or in wet conditions, indicating a design flaw in the tail light housing.
When: Occurs during/after rain
Symptoms owners cite: Water runs from tail lights into trunk on both sides; Leakage from tail light lenses during wet conditions
Repairs/costs cited: Returned to dealer; repair outcome not specified
Fog light fire
Passenger side fog light caught on fire while the vehicle was idling. Owner extinguished the fire. No inspection was performed to determine cause.
When: At 116,497 miles
Symptoms owners cite: Fog light caught on fire while vehicle idling
Repairs/costs cited: No diagnostic testing performed
Recalls/TSBs owners mention: Manufacturer notified and provided case number 15930173
Synthesized from 22 NHTSA owner complaints — unverified consumer
allegations, summarized for patterns. The verbatim filings appear below.