Free. Instant. No signup. Pulls recalls and complaints for your exact vehicle.

Couldn't find that VIN. Check the digits and try again.

ProblemsByVin Index / 2009-SUBARU-FORESTER / COMPLAINTS
Full complaint record · NHTSA

2009 Subaru Forester owner complaints

178 complaints filed with NHTSA on this vehicle , including 3 reporting a crash, fire, injury, or fatality. Showing the 300 most recent — grouped by category for scanning.

electrical 5 complaints shown

21 total in this category · severe · avg repair $850 · see electrical cluster analysis →
12/19/2015 98,613 mi ODI #10811257.0

On 12/19/2015 after starting the vehicle the radio, cigar lighter, temperature/time, and electronic mirror control would not operate. The vehicle was driven on a secondary street. After shutting the vehicle off and on the aforementioned items began to function again. Fuses were checked and all fuses seem to be in tact. The inability to control the external mirrors are a safety concern.

12/08/2008 4,615 mi ODI #10251120.0

Ignition doesn't recognize valet key, "security" light on dash comes on, key won't turn and car won't start. *tr

11/23/2014 41,312 mi ODI #10660313.0

I have a Subaru 2009 that I bought last yeay with around 25000 miles under an extended warranty . VIN [xxx] . And this as happened te times so far . While driving or just starting of the car shakes very hard , and the stability control light comes on the check engine ad cruise control and as the car tries to shift the whole car shakes . Then as you are driving down the highway it loses power almost as if it is stalling out . It did this to me on interstate 85 at 65 MPH and I barely missed a truck. I have contacted the dealer ship twice and taken it in once and they said nothing was wrong ? Now that I almost wrecked last night I am contacting you . Information redacted pursuant to the freedom of information act (foia), 5 u.s.c. 552(b)(6). *tr

11/18/2014 45,000 mi Crash ODI #10658934.0

I was going around a cup-de-sac to stop to a have my passenger exit the car to her house, I heard engine rev and push forward into her hollow tile wall, garden and down the other side of her property and stop on the wall before I thought of turning the engine off. *tr

11/15/2017 120,000 mi ODI #11046380.0

Tl* the contact owns a 2009 Subaru forester. The contact stated that various electrical systems, such as some warning indicators, wipers, and the defroster, ceased to function. The failures occurred without warning and would correct themselves once the vehicle was manually restarted. The failures occurred on five occasions. Autonation Subaru in spokane valley, wa could not replicate the failure. The manufacturer was notified. The failure mileage was approximately 120,000.

other 4 complaints shown

12/31/2015 46,345 mi ODI #10817214.0

While driving on 95 interstate I notice a crack sound and the left side of my driver's seat collapsed, rather dangerous! This is very uncomfortable especially since I have scoliosis. I am sitting at a diagonal position while driving and this is very distracting and uncomfortable. . I do not have the funds to pay to have this fixed and I see many others are having the same problem. I can lift the left side of my seat it is loose and sunken. I took it to the jones junction Subaru dealership in md. To ask if there were any recalls and they said no and they never heard of such a thing. I feel this is a safety issue and should be recalled. I only had 46,000 miles on my car at the time. I have reported this to bbb and consumer reports. Also I will be contacting soa.

12/11/2018 165,000 mi ODI #11160795.0

I purchased a 2009 Subaru forester through the Kia dealership in west chester, pa. I paid $5,600 for this used car, believing it was a good deal based on the salesman's recommendation. During the process, they told me of the repairs that may be needed, but with no mention of the exhaust system specifically. Five weeks later, I was driving home on back roads and heard a loud sound. I discovered the car's exhaust system had broken off, due to severe rust. The entire system was rusted out and falling apart. My mechanic later informed me that the car never should have been sold given this dangerous, terminal issue and that it was not at all safe to operate. I was shocked to find this out. I was distinctly told that it would be a very safe and reliable car for my family to own. The s

12/03/2009 21,000 mi ODI #10294344.0

I am writing to you today with great regret. After a lot of researching and thought, I purchased the Subaru forester on august 2008 from dunning Subaru ann arbor mi 48103. What drew me towards the forester was the 4 wheel drive so I was very happy to purchase this car. I was very happy with it up till a couple of months ago when I started experiencing problems. First, after returning from an oil change on may 2009, I came home and packed my car. Later when I went back to the garage, the floor was filled with oil because it was dripping from the engine; I was terribly upset and contacted Subaru right away. They asked me to come back and took care of it. Again, on november 29th I was on my way back from dropping my daughter at wayne state university when engine suddenly just stopped. It sta

11/12/2019 ODI #11279714.0

Weird things have been happening with my car, I know that someone is using the satellite radio port to tamper with the safety of my car. I took it to the shop it has a brand new engine in it, the steering light system flashing isn't even relevant to a problem that it could have. Everything listed on targeted cars, has happened with my car.

powertrain 3 complaints shown

12 total in this category · critical · avg repair $2,500 · see powertrain cluster analysis →
12/20/2011 59,800 mi ODI #10440629.0

Fails to function in drive when parked overnite and the outside temperature is below 40 degrees. After a warm up period the drive gear engages and the car is drivable except for a clunking and slippage of the transmission, also reverse appears ok until you place the car in drive and you a rattling clunk. The transmission RPM goes into the red zone at times while driving the car . *tr

12/19/2018 130,000 mi Fire ODI #11162616.0

Was driving about 20 MPH on a 2 lane secondary road when an approaching vehicle's driver got my attention and said my car was on fire. I found a place to safely pull off the road and directed my spouse to quickly get out, move away from our car and call 911. There was smoke coming from under the hood so I opened it carefully and saw a wall of flame, just above the catalytic converter, and approximately the width of the radiator and about 6 inches in height. I had a bottle of water with me which I used to douse the flames before the fire department arrived. I had the car towed to my local repair shop where our mechanic found a burst transmission fluid cooling line which had sprayed fluid into the lower engine compartment and onto the hot catalytic converter which ignited the fluid. Just be

12/04/2012 85,000 mi ODI #10487287.0

Tl* the contact owns a 2009 Subaru forester. The contact stated that while driving approximately 25 MPH, a vibration harmonic buzz was heard from underneath the vehicle. The vehicle was taken to the dealer for repair. The technician stated the heat shield needed to be repaired. The vehicle was taken to the dealer a second time for the same failure and same repairs were done. The manufacturer was made aware of the failure and stated the vehicle was not included in any recalls. The vehicle was not repaired. The approximate failure mileage was 85,000 and the current mileage was 90,000...updated 01/14/13 *bf updated 1/15/2013 *js

airbags 2 complaints shown

39 total in this category · severe · avg repair $1,100 · see airbags cluster analysis →
12/06/2016 52,000 mi ODI #10930141.0

Takata recall last week, I received a letter from Subaru of america telling me that parts are available to replace my defective takata air bag. However, the local dealer (landers mclarty Subaru, huntsville, al) says that parts are not available, and they cannot tell me when parts will be available. I think that landers mclarty Subaru is not being truthful with me - that they are trying to avoid as many air bag replacements as possible.

11/29/2016 ODI #10928513.0

Tl* takata recall. The contact owns a 2009 Subaru forester. The contact received notification of NHTSA campaign number: 16v358000 (air bags) however, the part to do the repair was unavailable. The contact stated that the manufacturer exceeded a reasonable amount of time for the recall repair. The manufacturer was made aware of the issue. The contact had not experienced a failure. Part distribution connect. Updated 01/05/2017*ct updated 02/13/17.*jb the vehicle was repaired. Updated 09/08/2017*js

engine 2 complaints shown

28 total in this category · severe · avg repair $3,100 · see engine cluster analysis →
12/01/2008 9,610 mi ODI #10250442.0

At 9610 miles my 2009 Subaru foresters engine failed. The failure came; as best I could tell; in about 20miles of operation. Engine started to sound louder from cabin. If I was parked with the engine running and the door open the noise was very load multi tone metal banging emanating from engine bay. Burning smell also occurred. As I drove the last 20 miles engine would barely stay running at low rpms; engine banging became worse; engine power appeared to decrease and a loud metallic grinding noise increased until check engine light went on. Approx 10-15 seconds latter. Engine completely stopped and never turned over again. Dealer told me today that car needs new engine. *tr

11/23/2012 52,500 mi ODI #10485863.0

I was driving to work, and the car wouldn't accelerate, it also handled roughly. The check engine light, cruise control light was flashing, along with vehicle dynamics control warning light. I had my car towed, as it wasn't drivable. My local garage repaired my car, I received 4 new spark plugs, and an air filter. 9 days later the check engine light came on, as well as the cruise control light, and the vehicle dynamics warning light, again it was repaired, this had to do with the catalytic converter message, but all my local garage could find was a small leak near the manifold that they repaired. 2 days later the check engine light went on again, I now called my Subaru dealership, they replaced a faulty catalyst converter, and af sensor, the also changed my oil, as it was due, and suggeste

cruise control 1 complaint shown

14 total in this category · severe · avg repair $600 · see cruise control cluster analysis →
12/25/2010 14,000 mi Crash ODI #10372373.0

Sudden acceleration on a 2009 Subaru forrester. My wife was pulling into a parking space when the vehicle suddenly accelerated, crashing thru a brick wall, over a large a/c unit and into a building. *tr

lighting 1 complaint shown

12/22/2017 ODI #11056115.0

Recall for puddle lights--shortly after purchasing in 2017--I took car to rapid city sd courtesy Subaru. I was told that the puddle lights had been removed, and there weren't any put back in, nor did they have any and would have to order them. I was told they would call when they got them, but I have never heard from them.

Showing 300 of 178 total complaints. The full federal record is available at nhtsa.gov/vehicle/2009/Subaru/Forester#complaints.
Source: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) owner complaint database. Last synced 2026-06-28. Complaints are owner-submitted and unverified — the existence of a complaint is not proof of a defect, but a pattern of complaints around the same component is a signal worth weighing. Verify any specific filing at nhtsa.gov.
Sponsored
Get a free warranty quote →