Check any vehicle by VIN

Free. Instant. No signup. Pulls recalls and complaints for your exact vehicle.

Couldn't find that VIN. Check the digits and try again.

ProblemsByVin Checklist / 2009-TOYOTA-HIGHLANDER

Pre-purchase · Buyer's checklist

2009 Toyota Highlander inspection checklist

The 2009 Toyota Highlander has 1 critical safety recall and a documented pattern of issues across 6 component categories. Before you sign anything, walk through this list with the seller. Skip nothing — the items below come from 134 owner reports already on file with NHTSA.

1 Verify safety recalls before you drive off

Recall fixes are free regardless of warranty status. Ask the seller for proof — or have the dealer pull the VIN history.

Toyota is recalling certain model year 2008-2010 highlander, model year 2009-2010 corolla, venza and matrix passenger vehicles — fix: Toyota will modify or replace the accelerator pedals on the subject vehicles. Floor surface modifications are also being considered and will be included for any model for which it is deemed appropriate. Initially, dealers will be instructed on how to reshape the accelerator pedal for the repair. As replacement parts with the same shape as the modified pedal become available, they will be made available to the dealers for the repair. Customers who have had the pedal reshape remedy completed will have the opportunity to receive a new pedal if they desire, after replacement pedals become available. In addition, Toyota will replace any Toyota all-weather floor mat in a subject vehicle with a newly designed mat, free of charge. For those customers who have the previous design all-weather floor mat but do not need or want the newly designed all-weather floor mat, Toyota will recover the previous design all-weather floor mat and reimburse its price. The safety recall began march 30, 2010. Owners may contact Toyota at 1-800-331-4331.
NHTSA 10V023000 · severity: critical

2 Inspect the engine

What to look for: Blue smoke on cold start (oil burning), white smoke at temperature (coolant), knock or tick that doesn't go away after warm-up, oil spots under the vehicle. (22 owner complaints on this vehicle · typical repair $3,100 · failures cluster ~87,721 mi)

Oil dipstick — level on the full mark, color amber not black, no milky residue (head gasket sign)
Coolant reservoir — level, no oil film floating, no rust
Spark plug wells (look down with a flashlight) — oil pooled means valve cover gasket
Timing chain or belt service history (interference engines = $1,500+ if it breaks)
Exhaust smoke briefly after a long idle then a rev

On the test drive: Drive until the gauge reaches operating temp, then check temp stability under load on a hill. Surging or temp climbing under load = thermostat or water pump.

See full engine report for this vehicle →

3 Inspect the brakes

What to look for: Pulsing brake pedal, pulling to one side when braking, squealing or grinding, soft pedal that goes to the floor. (20 owner complaints on this vehicle · typical repair $450 · failures cluster ~103,620 mi)

Brake pad thickness (look through the wheel spokes — at least 4mm material)
Rotor surface — deep grooves or lip on the outer edge means resurface or replace
Brake fluid color in the reservoir — should be light amber, not dark brown
ABS warning light cycles off after start

On the test drive: Hard brake from 40 mph in a safe spot — pedal should be firm, stop should be straight. A pulse means warped rotors ($300–$600).

See full brakes report for this vehicle →

4 Inspect the electrical

What to look for: Dim or flickering dash lights at idle, slow window operation, intermittent infotainment glitches, parasitic battery drain (dead battery after a few days parked). (19 owner complaints on this vehicle · typical repair $850 · failures cluster ~71,468 mi)

Battery age sticker — most batteries last 3–5 years
Alternator output at idle (13.8–14.5V is healthy)
All exterior lights: headlights both beams, taillights, brake lights, reverse, blinkers
Every interior switch: power windows, locks, mirrors, sunroof, seats
Infotainment cold-start time and touchscreen responsiveness

On the test drive: Cycle through every electronic accessory during the drive — heated seats, defrosters, climate fan on max, cruise control. Glitches show up under load.

See full electrical report for this vehicle →

5 Inspect the steering

What to look for: Wandering on the highway, clunks when turning, slop in the wheel before the tires respond, power steering whine. (11 owner complaints on this vehicle · typical repair $700 · failures cluster ~101,104 mi)

Tire wear pattern — uneven wear across the tread means alignment or worn suspension
Power steering fluid level (where applicable — most newer vehicles are electric)
Tie rod boots and ball joint boots for tears
Steering wheel free play — should be less than 1 inch at the rim

On the test drive: On a smooth highway, take hands off briefly (when safe) — vehicle should track straight. Pulling left or right means alignment or worn front-end parts.

See full steering report for this vehicle →

6 Inspect the cruise control

What to look for: Cruise that won't set, drops out on small inclines, jerky speed adjustment. (10 owner complaints on this vehicle · typical repair $600 · failures cluster ~37,769 mi)

Cruise stalk or steering wheel controls — every button function
On a flat road at highway speed, set cruise and verify it holds within 1–2 mph
Brake switch behind the pedal — if loose, cruise won't engage

See full cruise control report for this vehicle →

7 Inspect the body

What to look for: Paint mismatch between panels (prior accident), rust on rocker panels and wheel wells, door alignment gaps that don't match side-to-side, weatherstrip wear. (9 owner complaints on this vehicle · typical repair $1,500 · failures cluster ~55,907 mi)

Panel gaps — should be even and consistent; tight on one side means body work
Trunk and hood weatherstrips for cracks
Inside the trunk, under the spare — water staining means a leak
Door hinge bolts for paint dust (telltale of door replacement)
VIN plate on the dash matches the VIN sticker on the door jamb

See full body report for this vehicle →

8 Paperwork — before you sign

The seller's transparency on these tells you what kind of seller you're dealing with.

Title in seller's name (not "open title" or "signed by previous owner")
Service records — at least the last 24 months
VIN on the dash matches the door jamb sticker and the title
Run a paid vehicle history report (Carfax or AutoCheck) — accident, salvage, odometer rollback
Confirm any open recalls have been completed (NHTSA VIN lookup)
If financing, get the rate in writing before you set foot on the lot

Inspection items derived from 134 owner complaints and 9 active recall campaigns filed with NHTSA on the 2009 Toyota Highlander. Category-specific guidance is written by ProblemsByVin contributors with ASE-certified mechanic review. This checklist is meant to surface known patterns — it doesn't replace a paid pre-purchase inspection by a qualified shop, which we recommend for any used vehicle priced over a few thousand dollars.