Subaru Legacy reliability by year
52 recall campaigns and 1,840 owner complaints across 21 model years. Best year to buy: 2022. Year to avoid: 2012.
Worst model years to avoid → — the single year to avoid for every model line we track, ranked side by side.
Years to avoid — and why 9 flagged on the NHTSA record
Cleaner on the data: 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024 and others. Still verify the specific vehicle.
At-a-glance: every year color-coded
Each cell shows the last two digits of the model year and its 0–10 reliability score from NHTSA data. Click any year to see the full record. ★ best year · ✕ year to avoid.
Year-by-year reliability 21 model years · newest first
Per-year recall counts add up to 146, more than the 52 campaigns above, because a single NHTSA campaign often covers several model years and is counted once in each.
Common trouble spots across the Legacy aggregated across 21 model years
Common questions
What's the best year to buy a Subaru Legacy?
Based on NHTSA complaint volume and severity weighting, the 2022 Subaru Legacy scores 8.0/10 — the strongest in the 2005–2025 range. 32 complaints on file, 2 active recalls. Reliability scores reflect the federal complaint record, not subjective owner reviews.
Which Subaru Legacy year should I avoid?
The 2012 Subaru Legacy scores 2.0/10 — the weakest in the lineup. 90 owner complaints with NHTSA, 16 active recalls. That doesn't mean every 2012 is a problem — it means failure rates run higher than peer model years on the same platform.
Which years of the Subaru Legacy should I avoid?
On the NHTSA complaint and recall record, the model years to be most careful with are 2010 (avoid — the powertrain — powertrain: 45 complaints, classified severe, failures cluster 88,000–145,000 mi); 2005 (avoid — the engine — engine: 30 complaints, classified severe, failures cluster 30,000–74,000 mi); 2014 (high-risk ownership — reliability score 3.6/10 — below the segment average); 2013 (high-risk ownership — reliability score 3.0/10 — below the segment average); 2012 (high-risk ownership — reliability score 2.0/10 — below the segment average); 2011 (high-risk ownership — reliability score 2.0/10 — below the segment average). The cleaner years on the data are 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, 2020, 2019. This is our read of the federal data, not a substitute for a pre-purchase inspection of the specific vehicle.
How many years of the Subaru Legacy are tracked?
21 model years (2005 through 2025) with NHTSA records on file. Total across the lineup: 52 distinct recall campaigns and 1,840 owner complaints. Those campaigns land on 146 model-year entries in total, because one campaign often covers several years at once — which is why per-year recall counts add up to more than the campaign count.
What's the most-reported problem on the Subaru Legacy?
electrical is the most-reported category — 296 complaints across 18 model years. Average shop repair runs about $850.